I. Frederick Douglass, Stop Snitchin’ Son!: Slave Discourse and the Stop Snitchin’ Movement
Frederick Douglass’ narrative is a powerful piece of work. You can consider him your first black male feminist (shoutout to Dr. David Ikard and Dr. Mark Anthony Neal!) While he spoke to the horrific conditions of slaves in Maryland the one major characteristic that shines through Douglass’ narrative is the transcendence of being a slave into becoming a man. Something else that caught my attention was his refusal to disclose how he escaped from slavery: “I left my chains, and succeeded in reaching New York without the slightest interruption of any kind. How I did so, what means I adopted, what direction I travelled, and by what mode of conveyance, I must leave unexplained.” Here is an example of the Stop Snitchin’ Movement in 1838! Douglass refused to discuss his plan, which may have also been the plan for those runaway slaves enroute to the free states and Canada.
Where discretion was a survival technique in the 1800s, its Hip Hop descendant is….? I’m not quite sure what the point of the Stop Snitchin’ Movement is. The Boondocks aired an episode where Riley, keeping to the code of the streets (Chicago streetcode in white suburbia...comedy!), refuses to point out his friends for a rash of neighborhood robberies. In retaliation, Riley’s grandfather hides his bike “with the rims on it” and Riley frantically pleads with Grandad to tell him who stole it. Other examples would be the Stop Snitchin’ videos and merchandise that flooded mainstream culture with celebrities like Carmelo Anthony warning others “don’t be a snitch! Then you’re a bitch ass nigga!” (Sidenote: The Bitchassness Movement started by Diddy is its own blog.)
What is fascinating about the slavery snitch and its Hip Hop successor is that the concept holds steadfast. In both cases, the snitch is not respected. They are perceived to be a sell-out and disloyal to their people (whether racially or personal associates). And they are willingly telling valuable information about illegal dealings (remember, folks, hiding slaves or being affiliated with a runaway slave in any form was a crime in slave holding territories).
The context, however, changes. Jay-Z’s spits “I’m from the era where niggas don’t snitch/you’re from the era where snitchin’ is the shit” demonstrates a different contextualization of the snitch than in Douglass’ narrative. The most evident change is the shift of illegal activity – instead of bodies being transported, its the illegal dealing of drugs, murder, or gang affiliation. The criminal life is glorified and those who can correct the problem are ostracized or killed. Shows like Gangland and The First 48 reiterate that fact when speaking with witnesses to horrific crimes or a suspect’s associate. The first thing out of their mouth is “man, I ain’t no [insert expletive here] snitch.” Their names, identities, and voices are changed in fear of their lives. I don’t really understand the Gangland concept, though. They give the informant’s street name (the one that people know you by) and sometimes even show their face…but I digress.
I’m still playing around with ideas here but snitching as a trope is one pliable avenue to investigate the residual traces of slavery discourse and how it’s being expressed in contemporary black culture, especially in rap and Hip Hop.
II. Gucci Juice
I don’t knock Gucci Mane’s hustle. I can respect that. What I CAN’T respect is his lyricism or the lack thereof. Lemon Pepper Wings (WANGS), freeze cups, and bus schedules can only go so far. Dude is coonin’! And so is his boy OJ da Juiceman.
In my Gender Performance and Black Culture course we’re about to start talking about the coon figure. A plantation archetype, the coon is illiterate, inarticulate, and simple. In other words, he or she is an over exaggerated black stereotype that appeals to a non-black audience. Gucci Mane and OJ da Juiceman do that. They are Hip Hop coons.
While I find 2% of Gucci’s music somewhat tolerable, OJ da Juiceman can’t even finish his “ay!” catchphrase before he gets turned off. What most upsets me about Juiceman was his XXL online guest blog in August 2009. He literally spelled out what he said. While not saying anything at all. Not only does this reaffirm those stereotypical notions of blacks being unable to relay their thoughts through written expression, he is from the south. Southern blacks are fighting an uphill battle as it is. We’re not just backwards, beat-and-booty-driven. Our real lyricists are being overshadowed by those fools who are just following or contributing to the latest dance craze. Or speaking a whole bunch of uh-uh.
III. Sprite Stepoff
I saved this for last on purpose. Here’s my .08 cents. Yes, eight. Three words – Hot Ass Mess.
It started off decent enough. I was in attendance and had some great seats. We started at 6:00pm (don’t they know good stepshows NEVER start on time?! lol) and the events didn’t end until 2:00am. From start to finish, there were 20 teams. TWENTY! Fourteen of those teams were for the actual stepoff teams that Sprite sponsored. The good folks at Sprite must’ve forgotten that stepping is almost as sacred as rituals for any Black Greek Letter Organization (hereafter BGLO). They must’ve also overlooked the concept of having judges who are familiar with stepping and what to look for in a show instead of strictly celebrity judges who were judging simply because of their celebrity status or their affiliations. What Sprite banked on was the popularity and recent wave of steppers as a fad in American popular culture. This isn’t really anything new… the commodification of African American Culture. But you didn’t come to Red Clay Scholar for me to rehash what has already been discussed.
Greeks, I’m looking at us. As a woman of Alpha Kappa Alpha, I was appalled and embarrassed to be in attendance. I’m not going to comment on who should have won. What got me was the deplorable behavior by members of BGLOs who were wearing jackets, other (parapher)’nalia, and identifying themselves with XYZ organization while throwing racist slurs, fighting each other, and just being straight ignant (yes folks, the ultimate level of ignorance is IGNANT). During Zeta Tau Alpha’s performance, audience members who didn’t approve of a white sorority participating in the competition chanted “white bitches shouldn’t step” and boo’ed a great performance. Here’s what bothered me further: we were being taped for a show that was looking for some drama to pop off. And we gave it to them. I told ya’ll that Kum Bah Yah mentality was for the birds.
Food for thought: We are no longer just African American. We are international, interracial, and interconnected. While I’m not suggesting that ALL BGLO members think in such a manner, it’s a bad look for an overall network that is already under constant scrutiny. Let’s not give them something to add to that fire that’s already burning out of control.
Friday, February 26, 2010
G.I.I.F.T. (Get It In Friday Thoughts) Vol. I
Filed Under
BGLOs,
Frederick Douglass,
Gucci Mane,
OJ da Juiceman,
Snitching,
Sprite Stepoff
| Reactions: |
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)




I only have a comment for the Stop Snitchin' segment.
ReplyDeleteI believe there is a difference between snitching and being a witness. If Mr. Douglass did give details of his escape, then that would be snitching.
If a drug dealer is arrested by the cops and spills the beans on his partners & associates, that too is snitching.
Now if I happen to witness a crime, well, I'm a witness. I'm not involved in the illegal dealings so I'm not a snitch.
I think the lines between snitching & being a witness have been crossed in the minds of some that choose to participate in illegal activities. A snitch will enjoy the fruits of the crime until caught, and then will take everyone down with them (usually in exchange for some sort of favor). A snitch, in many cases, is a coward.
A witness that comes forward is at times a concerned citizen or someone who knows they have a civic duty to perform. But the lines are being blurred and distorted. Those that would be witnesses are at times fearful for their safety or being incorrectly labeled a snitch. That way, crime continues & securing witnesses willing to testify becomes one of the toughest challenges for police officers to put repeat, unrepentant criminals behind bars.
Sorry to hear about the incident at the step show... Nice post.
ReplyDeleteI think one of the major reasons that our music and culture have not advanced to an acceptable level, and allowed such things as coonin', is because Hip Hop music and it's fans never made a lane wide enough for an emcee to speak to the adults in Hip Hop (or allow those emcee's to make enough money to bitter the lure of going pop). Someone decided it wasn't marketable enough as music grown folks would listen to and support, so those who were in it just for the money, went where the money was. Adults on the mic began speaking almost exclusively to kids. Sadly, often the only adults speaking to them at all.
We didn't sit them down and make them listen to things that were good for them. We didn't make them listen to music that brought about emotions other than malice and indifference. Hip Hop kept speaking to the youth while those of us born into Hip Hop got grown.
Hip Hop wasn't talking to adults, so the adults tuned out. How many people you know say they ain't bought a Hip Hop album in years?...We tuned out and let this B.S. slip thru. We moved on without Hip Hop (to a certain extent) and left it behind instead of demanding that it come with us. Grow with us...
I think we've realized our mistakes and generally can agree that Hip Hop has to be a tool to help the people get better.
Peace. Power.
I think Gucci Mane is a brilliant artist. I've been fascinated with his music over the last three years.
ReplyDeleteGucci Mane has extremely good at turning common hood rhetoric into abstraction. His thought patterns aren't linear which makes his rhymes appear elementary, but they are far from it. He's no different than Kool Keith, Ghostface Killah around the turn of the century, and many others.
His biggest strength is that he's able to create worlds/atmospheres that absolutely capture the listener. When I listen to "Lemonade," I feel like I'm in the Twilight Zone. Its like I've been unconsciously drawn into some alternate universe. His lyrics, disconnected flow, and Zaytoven's twisted beats all contribute to this. I think Gucci's making some of the most creative music out there. Much more creative than Drake's punchlines, Jay-Z's Big Daddy Kane/Notorious B.I.G. steez, or whatever Young Jeezy's doing now (though I like Jeezy).
Hip Hop is youth culture and I do not see a problem with that. It will always be situated within the experiences of 16 - 23 year-olds. I think this is true of any American popular music genre. The folks listening to Credence Clear Water revival in the 1970s are unlikely to listen to the Killers. Those who copped R.E.M.'s "Automatic for the People" when it came out might not have bought that Kings of Leon record. That's just the way it is.
Mainstream hip hop is always going to be what it is. When are we going to cease caring about what type of artist gets respected by whom? Since the early 1990s, the "best" lyricists on every coast have been underground. That's just the way it is. Its the same argument that happens in rock, indie vs. mainstream. Jay isn't the most lyrical artist in New York. Drake isn't in Canada. The Game is far from it in California. It's fair play.
All hip hop does not have to be cerebral. Hip Hop can be consumed in your ride, your bedroom, through headphones, and on the dance floor. Its all worthy of respect.
This coon label gets thrown around a lot in hip hop and mostly from the Black middle class and "educated." This is funny considering that hip hop wasn't originally made for us. The same things you're saying about Gucci Mane now was said about PE, Slick Rick, and NWA by the middle class in the 80s. Everybody wants a voice. Everybody wants to be heard. That's only human. The beautiful thing about hip hop is that it allows folks to do just that, no matter what type of situation they are in. Don't be mad at Gucci and OJ for talking (positively or negatively) about their experiences. If you have a problem with content, seek to change the socio-economic situation that informs it.
I applaud Gucci, OJ, Project Pat and all these cats for riding their own wave. Who's the true coon? The one who stays true to his art as much as he can or the one who sells his own out for the chance at millions of dollars and the right to sit courtside at Knicks games with Barbara Streisand? Hip Hop is fine. I've outgrown much of it, but I will always respect an MC who unashamedly makes music true to his experiences.